Create Your Own Hands-on Piano Piano Activities

Hands-on is Helpful.

I live in Cleveland Ohio in the U.S. There is a large and vibrant classical music community here due to the presence of the Cleveland Institute of Music. As a result, a lot of my student’s parents are musicians. At an introductory lesson, one pianist-father observed all of the hands-on -piano-activities his son was engaged in at the lesson. His comment was that piano pedagogy had come a long way since he had taken lessons as a boy. I believe this is true, largely because of all of the awesome sharing that takes place between all of us on the internet and on social media. There are so many great ideas and activities going around. I love to come up with hands-on activities myself, and I enjoy sharing them with our Paloma Piano community. In this post, I thought I would share how to create your own hands-on piano activities.

Resources are Everywhere!

For ten years, I worked as a preschool teacher in a Montessori School. The head teacher at our school was a highly trained Montessori Specialist and highly creative person. She taught me to see everything as a potential learning activity. Discarded keys became a matching lesson; old perfume bottles: an opportunity to sort and the match tops to the bottles; clothes pins and cloth: a chance to hone fine motor skills, and on and on. The shelves at our school were filled with learning activities; most of them handmade. I noticed that there were two main strategies to come up with new activities. I also knew that I could apply these ideas to piano teaching.

 

Strategy 1: Think of a Problem that Needs Solving

Is a preschool student having trouble remembering the names of the keys? Think of ways that could help him remember. Use things that are colorful, interesting to look at and to touch. For young students, I like to choose things that feel interesting and are large enough for little hands to grasp. I think of using the senses of sight, touch and sound together when creating activities for young students. Getting young students off of the piano bench periodically is also important.

Older students can benefit from hands-on activities as well. Visual aids can be used to teach theoretical concepts like how scales are constructed or how different triads are formed. More advanced students also love games and challenges. Is an older student having trouble memorizing? Think of ways to turn memorizing into a game or a challenge. Using these ideas you can create your own hands-on piano activities.

Strategy 2: See Something and Then Come up With Ways to Use It

There really are resources everywhere. Keep this in mind when shopping, cleaning out closets and drawers or just walking around outside. When you come across something interesting, ask yourself if it is something you can use in a piano lesson. This can be super fun and the more you practice coming up with ideas the better you will get at thinking of great and unique activities for your students.

Learn more about using games in your studio read the post “Piano Teaching Games”

Start With a Brain Dump

When trying to find ways to solve a problem or make use of an object. Write down every idea that comes to mind no matter how crazy it may seem. Inevitably some of these ideas will be good ones and ideas always lead to more ideas for you to create your own hands-on piano activities.

Here’s an example of how to create your own hands-on piano activities.

Jillian is 4 years-old she is having trouble understanding the concept of high notes being the on the right side of the keyboard and low notes being on the left side of the keyboard. I am going to think of ten crazy, off the cuff ways to help her.

  1. Take a paper keyboard chart turn it on its side so the right side of the keyboard is higher, then put it back down.
  2. Put a red bead or piece of paper on the right side of the keyboard and a red sticker on the paper flip it up and see how the red is high, use a different color for the low notes on the left side.
  3. Play a higher lower gameplay a note and have the student play a higher or lower note.
  4. Put a red sticker with an H on the student’s right hand use a different color for the left hand.
  5. Have the student put a red bead on the high side of every group of three black keys (B). Repeat with the low notes.
  6. Play a “Chase” game. Play a note have the student play a higher note as quickly as possible until the top of the keyboard is reached. Repeat for the low side of the keyboard.
  7. Use a small plastic bird and place it on the highest notes on the keyboard use something like a small fish for the low notes.
  8. Make up a little chant and movement activity to a simple tune like “Merrily We Roll Along” The high notes are on the right, on the right, on the right.” Etc.
  9. Have the student play a five-finger exercise and say the word “higher” on each note C through G. Reverse for the low notes.
  10. Have the student find a series of random notes each one must be higher (or lower) than the next. (for example; A, G, F. G must be higher than A and F higher than G)

Obviously, not all of these ideas are fantastic, but a couple of them are usable and one or two might really click with my student.

Try these exercises.

Think of some ways to help these students.

    1. Scott has been playing for three years but has trouble remembering Key Signatures.
    2. 5-year-old Sandra avoids using her thumb when playing.

Think of some ways the following objects could be used in a piano lesson. (You can add other objects to the ones suggested

    1. Pipe Cleaners
    2. Sea Shells
    3. Small Wooden Cubes

I know that teachers are such creative people and are always coming up with new ways to teach. I hope some teachers might find these ideas helpful. I would love to hear about how all of you come up with unique activities for your students.

If you like this post please share it.

If you would like lots of free printable music and resources you can use in your studio become a Paloma Piano member.

Visit our sister-site for parents and students pianoparents.net

A Heart for Teaching Piano Teachers

Here is the second part of last week’s blog post. A heart for teaching piano teachers.

Continued.

Everything has a downside

While it true that sharing and posting are 99.9% fantastic and I learn so much, I can’t help but think of my younger self. The Doreen who’d just graduated from college not feeling so confident. Let’s face it, music school isn’t for the faint of heart. I worked hard, but when I came out I didn’t feel prepared for the real world of the working musician or the piano teacher. Even if I’d had the courage to pipe up and ask a question on social media I surely would have been easily discouraged if someone would have come back with a judgmental comment.

Continue reading “A Heart for Teaching Piano Teachers”

Preschool Piano Skills and Goals

What does it mean to be the best piano teacher in town? It means having preschool piano skills and goals that will attract and maintain great students. Here are some benefits.

1) You have a full studio with a waiting list.

2) Students and Parents are happy.

3) You can charge a premium rate for lessons.

4) You will get many referrals.

5) You love teaching.

 

The Benefits of Teaching Preschool Students. Preschool Piano Skills and Goals

1) Preschoolers become great older students.

2) Preschoolers increase your enrollment.

3) Preschoolers are fun to teach.

 

Working With Preschool Piano Students

1) Young children learn best using a multi-sensory approach.

2) Most preschoolers cannot sit for long periods of time, they need the opportunity to get up and move.

3) It is important to establish goals for preschoolers and have rubrics in place to measure the progress of your preschool students.

4) Parents need to see measurable progress with regard to their child’s piano study.

 

Goals For Preschool Piano Students

1) To learn strong aural skills.

2) To Play with excellent technique.

3) To understand how music works.

4) To memorize and improvise music.

5) To love the piano and become lifelong players.

Preschool Piano Skills

1) Lesson etiquette

2) Proper Posture

3) Finger Numbers

4) The Music alphabet

5) Treble and Bass Clefs

6) Names of the piano keys

7) Concentration

8) Stories of great composers

9) How to play along with the teacher and keep a steady beat

10) How to identify high and low sounds on the keyboard

11) The names of basic rhythmic value

12) The concept of organized sound

13) The concept of timbre

14) Dynamics

15) Tempo

16) Listening to great music

17) Recital Participation

18) Basic improvisation.

19) Singing and matching pitch.

Read the post “Little Kids on the Keys”

 

 

The “Preschool Activities Book” at Paloma Piano features activities for preschool students.

This Book is available for Paloma Platinum Members. Find out more here.

Visit our sister site

pianoparents.net

Why Teach Music History to Piano Students?

Music History…Music History! Are you still with me? Why teach music history to piano students?

Honestly, I used to hate my college Music History class. “Music Misery” does that ring a bell? The only thing mildly amusing about it was how excited the Professor used to get when telling stories about composers. The guy was really jazzed about the subject. Me? I didn’t care. I just wanted to pass the test and get on to playing the piano and composing strange sounding music. I just didn’t see the point. I felt that I needed to be in the practice room not sitting at a desk learning about the antics and escapades of Beethoven, Bach and Brahms. Continue reading “Why Teach Music History to Piano Students?”

Sight-Reading

Piano Sight-reading

Sight-reading piano music is no easy task! Actually reading piano music at all is no easy task. Being able to instantly play music that is set before you is nothing short of amazing. Some people are so good at it. It seems to come naturally to certain pianists others of us have to really work at sight-reading piano music.

I started playing the piano at the age of 12 (late!). I spent a lot of time practicing. I worked hard to prepare everything my teacher assigned. I did not, however, spend any time on sight-reading because I had a lot of catching up to do. It was all I could do to learn to play my classical repertoire, scales, and technique. As a result, I used to be a horrible sight-reader. This was not good! Not good at all.

When I got to college I soon discovered that my sight reading deficiency was a major problem. I was awed by my friends who could sight read anything. Life was so much less stressful for them. These students had the confidence to know that they could pretty much get through anything that was set in front of them during choral conducting or ensemble class. They could also play more pieces and learn them faster. I soon realized that being a strong sight reader is an indispensable skill for all pianists. So I set out to become a good sight-reader here’s how I did it, and how I teach my students to sight read.

Continue reading “Sight-Reading”

9 Tips for Teaching Teenage Beginning Piano Students

I started learning the piano at age 12. Which is kind of late musically speaking. The fact is the earlier in life you start piano lessons the better. But not everyone has the opportunity to begin lessons as a preschooler. There is a lot written about adult beginners, but what about teens? These students are in the middle, not young children and not adults. Teenage beginning piano students come with their own unique set of challenges and strengths. Here are some tips on teaching beginning teenage piano students.

Some Basic Tips

  1. Help teens set goals, Most teens are anxious to learn to play as quickly as possible. At the very first lesson, we talk about goals. What type of music they want to learn and how much time they have to spend practicing. Playing the piano is a big undertaking I let them know this from the beginning.
  2. Once I find out what it is teens want to learn I  put them on the Fast Track. Ultimately I want my teenaged beginning piano students to learn to read music, read a lead sheet and play by ear. Then end game is to have teenaged beginning students gain facility at the piano as quickly as possible so that they can enjoy playing and learn music independently.

What is the Fast Track?

    1. Music Reading, Of course, I use Paloma Piano’s Method books. Teenage beginning piano students who practice will be able to get through Books 1a through 4b within 1 to 2 years. After that, they should be proficient enough music readers to jump into intermediate classical music. I put my students into a book called “Music by the Masters”. This collection has a lot of great classical pieces from which to choose.
    2. Technique                                                                                                                                   With younger students I wait awhile to teach scales and arpeggios. However, I start right away with teenaged beginning piano students. They learn two octaves hands together (see the post-Learning Scales and Arpeggios the Easy Way). It’s also important to focus on relaxation of the hand and proper posture. With some students, I use a few of the first Hannon exercises.
    3. Music Theory                                                                                                                             I streamline it. All of the basic stuff (notes, rhythms, musical terms, etc.) are covered in the method books. Other than that, I teach whole steps and half steps, major and minor key signatures, scale degrees, and how to form chords.
    4. Improvisation                                                                                                                             I have students makeup music, play on the black keys, use the pedal and experiment with sounds. I feel that this helps them to get comfortable with the instrument. I am not a jazz teacher but I will teach my students a few Blues scales and left hand patterns so that they can have some fun. Sometimes I’ll make up a bass line and let them play over it.
    5. Playing by Ear                                                                                                                           This is an easy one just think of a song you know and plunk it out. After that add I, IV, V chords and go from there.
    6. Piano Covers                                                                                                                              A Piano Cover is a popular song played on the piano by someone other than the original artist who recorded it. Youtube is full of these. It is also full of Piano Tutorials and teens love them. I have my students show me what they are trying to learn from Youtube and I help them. I have mixed feelings about Youtube tutorials but I know that my teenaged beginning piano students are probably trying them. If they are getting their other work done and the tutorial looks like something they can accomplish I help them break it down and learn it.
    7. Chords and Lead Sheets                                                                                                        Once my teenage beginning students can read music fairly well I teach them how to form chords and play from a lead sheet. This, along with playing by helps them to learn some of the popular music they enjoy playing. If a student enjoys singing, all the better! Playing chords and singing is easy to learn and will really help them enjoy the piano.

In Conclusion

I really love working with teenage beginning piano students. They are so much fun and they learn very fast. Even though these students are very busy most of them are so excited to learn to play the piano that they will work very hard. I know how they feel I love the piano too! And I will do anything to help them attain their dream of playing the piano.

If you would like to receive free piano music.

button

Get the book! “The Happiest Piano Teacher in Town:

It’s chock full of great ideas and encouragement for piano teachers.

Put it on your reading list or read it with your piano teaching club or group.

 

Teaching Piano Students to be “Let Go” Players

Boy-jumping-off-a-cliff1Piano Students Need to Let Go!

Nicholas was playing the Beethoven Minuet in G Major when he suddenly lost his place in the trio section. “Ms. Hall where am I?” he asked. “Second line, second measure” I answered. My student then did something rather strange. He pointed to the measure with his nose. “You mean right here?” he asked again. I have seen this behavior before. This boy doesn’t want to let go of the keys. He is hanging on for dear life as though he may never find them again.

There is definitely a fear among less experienced players that they will lose their bearings on the keyboard. They feel that by being in close contact with the keys they will lessen the chances of making a mistake. It’s kind of like walking on a winding mountain trail, hugging side as closely as possible for fear of falling off of the edge. Just hang on and everything will OK.

But will it? While may or may not increase the chances of playing accurately this overly cautious playing can’t be very much fun for the player or an audience. In the end, this “Hang On” playing is not very musical and it’s not what I want for my students. I want my students to be “Let Go” players.

Playing the Piano is Fun!

I tell my students that in order to be a “Let Go” player you have to let go of the idea that playing the piano is something to worry about. Playing the piano is supposed to be fun! With some careful practice and the right mindset it can be. Let me explain how I teach my piano students to be “Let Go” players.

Right from the start while teaching piano students I teach beginners to lift and relax their hands. We practice playing a note using the pad of each finger and then lifting and gently closing the hand as if picking something up. After that, we work with several notes at a time, and them all five fingers. Playing, lifting and relaxing. I remind my students to relax and have fun. If I see a student getting nervous or hanging on to the keys I have them go back to their simple “Let Go” exercises.

For more advanced players I believe the key is to choose appropriate repertoire and practice letting go. If a piece is too difficult it is natural for a student to become stressed. Stress causes the student to be fearful of making mistakes, resulting in a stiff or “Hang On” style of playing. To combat this I intentionally have my students practice slowly with relaxed arms and hands. I use a “place and play” technique for practicing. This is especially effective for left-hand jumps. It works like this; play a note then go to the next note or chord as quickly as possible, place your fingers on the keys before depressing them. This allows muscle memory to come into play your hand and arm will remember just how far it has to go to get the right notes.

Something else that really helps is demonstrating “Let Go” playing while working with students and having the watch great concert pianists. This way they can see what “Let Go” playing looks like. I point out to them that music is a performance art and performance is about watching as well as listening. How we sound, look, and feel while we play determines the experience our audience will have.

I also make it a point to refer to my students as “pianists” from the very first lesson. I want them to see themselves as real musicians. I let them know that it doesn’t matter if they are playing “Mary Had a Little Lamb” or a Chopin Etude their job is to make the music they are playing beautiful, interesting and meaningful. Because that is what the art of music is all about.

Read the post, “Love Will Keep Us Together Helping Students Fall in Love With the Piano”

Playing the Piano is About Letting Go!

It was Beethoven who said, “To play a wrong note is insignificant, to play without passion is inexcusable”. Making music is not about perfection. As much as we all strive for the error-free performance, mistakes happen. Sometimes big ones! But playing music is about being human, about connecting with others. It should be something that makes people happy, and that includes the performer.

So, in conclusion, being a “Let Go” player is about preparing the music well and then enjoying the experience of playing the music. Playing the piano is awesome! That’s why (almost) everyone wishes they could. I encourage my students to have fun let go and play!

visit our sister site for parents and students pianoparents.net

If you like this content please share it. If you would like tons of free music and resources for your studio

button

Overachieving Piano Students

The Overachieving Student

Overachieving piano students, We love them! In fact, most of the piano teachers are overachievers so we can relate to them. Students who are willing to practice like crazy because they want so badly to be able to play the piano can be like a breath of fresh air for teachers who are used to trying to convince students to take practicing seriously. These awesome students don’t come along everyday and when they do we need to everything we can to assure they are successful. But I have found that is not always as easy as one would think.

smilingI have had experience with OA students in all age groups. I once had an OA four year old student who was determined to keep up with her two older brothers. Right now I have two students that fall into the OA category. One is a young man in the eighth grade the other is actually a retired adult student. The thing that all of the over achieving piano students students have in common is the dream of being able to play well.

So what’s the problem? Why worry about students who want to practice? They are better off than students who don’t practice, why not let them just go ahead and practice all they want?

Young Overachievers

We all agree that practicing is a good thing. That is the right kind of practicing. My four-year-old overachiever was determined to keep up with her two older brothers. They, of course, had the advantage as they were older and had started lessons before she did. Fortunately, her wise mother realized that she was trying too hard and gave me a “heads-up” on the situation. My student was practicing to the point of frustration. I was a younger teacher at the time and had never before faced a situation like this. All I saw was a little girl who was coming into with her lesson prepared every week, prompting me to keep up the pace of the assignments I was giving her.

The danger here was that my student could have become overwhelmed, putting her at risk of becoming discouraged or even giving up on the piano altogether.

My solution was to give my student less work, more praise and to let her know that she was not expected to keep up with her brothers. I am so glad that her mother let me know what was going on. Now I make sure to ask parents and students how the practicing is going. I ask how much time they are spending assignments and whether they are finding the work I am giving them too difficult or too easy.

Teen-aged overachieving piano students

The eighth-grade student I have right now is a fantastic young man I’ll call Jonah. He loves the piano and is an overachieving piano student. He started this year and I know he wants to make up for lost time. He completes every assignment I give him and then some. He never misses his lesson. Jonah is super intelligent. I have no doubt that he will learn to play the piano, no matter what! but I want him to reach his goals as quickly as humanly possible. The operative word here is “humanly”. We can only absorb so much at one time. I want to give him plenty of music at each level to work with and I don’t want him to skip ahead too fast. I want to make sure he can read the music, understand and execute what he is working on before advancing to the next level.

Jonah, like most young people, loves popular music. He frequently comes into his lesson with music he has learned by watching Youtube tutorials. Personally, I am all for this. I use this as an opportunity to teach theory, chords and ear training. However, I prefer that my students learn to play popular music by listening to the original song and then getting some ideas by listening to other pianists play covers. I find that the tutorials usually move either way too fast or ways to slow. Besides, I want my students to begin plunking out tunes by themselves and learning to hear chord changes on their own.

The danger for Jonah is that he will advance faster than his mind can absorb musical knowledge and faster than his hands and body can develop the proper technique. I don’t want him to spend to much time on things like Youtube tutorials or worse, learn to play instantly schemes. He may have unrealistic expectations and become disheartened or he may even give up.

My solution is to give Jonah music that allows plenty of practice at each level and check to make absolutely sure that he is reading all of the notes and rhythms independently and correctly. I know he is doing a lot of playing and advancing quickly so I started him on technique and scales right away. I work with him to set attainable goals for his playing and how to manage practicing so that he can meet his goals.

Read the post, “9 Tips for Teaching Beginning Teenaged Piano Students”

Adult overachievers

My adult student is in her seventies. Joan is a smart, youthful woman who has always dreamed of playing the piano. I love working with her! She arrives every Tuesday at 3 pm “with bells on” ready to work. Joan has been studying for about a year and a half and I think she is doing very well. Joan tells me she practices at home about two hours a day, which is a lot for this very busy lady. She has high standards and sometimes becomes frustrated with her playing. I want her to reach her goal of playing the piano but I also want her to enjoy it along the way.

The danger for Joan is that she will not enjoy learning to play the piano. She will push herself so hard that she won’t have fun with the piano.

The solution is to assign her music she likes and can learn fairly easily. We work on a combination of music that she reads, music that uses chords, and pieces she can play by rote. The lessons need to be super fun and Joan needs lots of encouragement. After all, Joan is an amazing person!

I have seen over achieving piano students do a few other things to try to learn to play faster. Things like writing in notes and then erasing them before the lesson or having a parent or sibling teach them the music by rote so that they seem prepared for the lesson. Anything that can hold them back, in the long run, should be avoided. The goal is to create independent players.

I have focused this post on overachieving piano students in the beginning stages of piano study. While there can be advanced students who are overachievers the issues are different. Most advanced students who choose to practice a lot are able to handle it without any problems.

Overachieving piano students certainly make great students. However, they need to realize that learning to play the piano is a long-term project. It’s difficult for everyone and there are no shortcuts. Enjoying the process of learning is vital to the continued success of these students. As teachers, we can help them realize their dream of being able to play the piano. How awesome is that? Not only are we so very blessed to be pianists ourselves, but we get to pass that awesomeness along to others!

All of my overachievers are doing well. My four-year-old student is now 19 years old she graduated last year after studying with me for 14 years. She is a fine pianist as are her brothers who I also had the privilege of teaching until graduation and beyond.

If you like this content please share it. If you would like hundreds of pages of free piano games, music and resources become a Paloma Piano forever free Gold Member today.

button

Visit our sister site for students and parents pianoparents.net

10 Tips For Accurate Piano Playing

 Accurate Piano Playing

“Ms. Doreen, which instrument is the easiest to play?” I get this question quite often. Though I’m not sure why my students want to know. A few probably are trying to find an easier project but I suspect most of my kids are proud to be taking on the challenge of playing piano. Many of them have friends who play other instruments so it may be a bit of the old “my instrument’s harder than your’s” routine.

I tell my students that all instruments are difficult in one way or another. For pianists reading piano music and playing all of the notes and rhythms correctly is difficult indeed. So here are a few tips that may help your students play accurately;

10 Tips for Accurate Piano Playing

  1. Choose the right piece. Something that is on or just above the student’s level.
  2. Peruse the piece with your student. Check out rhythm, notes, key changes, and things like that.
  3. Have your student listen to accurate recordings of the piece. Your student will need your guidance especially if he/she relying on Youtube videos (as many of my students do). Not all Youtube performances are created equal.
  4. After sight reading through the piece I recommend hands separate practice with super careful attention to fingering. I harp incessantly on fingering with my students I explain to them that consistent fingering is crucial for accurate playing. Getting the right fingers on the right notes at the right time is the name of the game when it comes to playing accurately.
  5. “Hesitate, don’t make a mistake” This recommendation comes from a book called “The Pianist’s Problems” by William S. Newman. In a perfect world my students would always play with rhythmic accuracy, but I have found that it is better to hesitate and get the correct notes and fingerings than to forge ahead and play the right rhythm but the wrong notes.
  6. Practice carefully with the right mindset. I tell my students it isn’t just about how much time you spend practicing. You need to focus and practice as accurately as possible.Try not to practice mistakes. Otherwise you will actually spend time at the piano and play worse than when you started!
  7. Use the metronome. I call it my music “cleaner”. I know the metronome is a controversial tool, but I am a big believer in using it as a practice tool for intermediate level players and higher. Have students start so slowly that it is easy to get all of the notes, rhythm, fingering, articulation, phrasing and dynamics perfect. Repeat increasing the tempo by 2-8 beats per minute each time. This technique works miracles!
  1. Decide whether or not your student will memorize or use the score. If the piece is to be memorized do so quickly. I find that my students have accuracy problems whenever pieces are half memorized. I tell my students either play from totally memory or use the music. Don’t memorize and keep the music in front of you as a fail-safe.
  2. Once pieces are memorized refer to the score from time to time. One of my teachers once pointed out that his colleagues who never went back to the music once they had memorized a piece always had trouble playing accurately during concerts. I found this to be true as it is easy to change things little over time, and as a result have trouble playing perfectly.
  3. Tell your students to stay calm. There is an old saying among musicians; “The amateur practices until he gets it right, the professional practices until he can’t possible get it wrong.” It is possible to practice so much and so well that you really can relax and trust that you know the music. Having confidence and getting nerves under control will help anyone to play better.

While it is possible for students to play the piano accurately it is also likely that mistakes will happen from time to time. Almost no one plays perfectly all of time. Flawless playing (or the illusion of flawless playing) comes with time and experience. So I believe it’s important to teach our students to keep going and do their best. And above all, enjoy playing and play musically.

“To play a wrong note is insignificant to play without passion is inexcusable.”

…Ludwig van Beethoven

If you like this content please share it. If you would like free piano music you can download and print for your studio.

button

The Perfectionistic Piano Student

The Perfectionistic Piano Student

Have you ever had an experience with a student that just doesn’t compute? You know the child is smart. She’s in the gifted program at school yet she doesn’t seem to understand what you are trying to teach her. She is reluctant to try new things and wants to focus on the easy stuff. She begs for only a small amount of music to practice each week. She doesn’t seem to be enjoying the lesson at all. So what gives? Is it me? Does this student just hate the piano? Is she unmotivated? Maybe it’s none of these things. Maybe she is the perfectionistic piano student.

Now granted, I haven’t seen many

perfectionists in my piano studio. In fact, the vast majority of my
students could use a little dose of perfect. I spend most of my time
trying to get kids to count and play the correct notes. A student who
wants to play perfectly is an exciting prospect! After all perfection
or at least near perfection is what we musicians strive for. So how
can we spot the perfectionistic student, and more importantly how can
we nurture this person so that she will become a happy and successful
pianist?

5vwj5n8x-1394488827

Traits of the perfectionistic piano student

Shy doesn’t talk much at the
lesson.
Reluctant to try new things, plays
each note very slowly and carefully.
Takes on less work than she is
capable of accomplishing.
Sensitive to criticism.
Nervous or distracted at the
lesson.
Does not practice sufficiently at
home.
Plays in a mechanical fashion,
without much feeling.
The easiest way to confirm the
suspicion that a particular student may be a perfectionist is simply
to ask her. “Are you afraid to get this wrong?” At this point, the
student will probably say yes and give a sigh of relief.

What to do

Now that you know your student has
unreasonably high standards, you can begin to formulate a plan to
work with her. I always begin by telling my perfectionist student how
valuable she is, how wonderful it is to really want to get things
right. I tell my little perfectionist (and her parents) that she is
in the right place. If she loves to focus on the details and produce
a polished product, then the piano is a great place to do those
things.

But, that is not the end of it. There
is a real danger in being a perfectionistic piano student. After all,
who’s perfect? We wish we all were. At times some pianists play
perfectly, but living with mistakes and mishaps are part of the game.
We must teach our students that everything doesn’t have to be
flawless to be good. In fact, mistake-free playing does not equal
good playing. Playing the piano is about more than hitting the right
keys at the right time, (no disrespect to Mr. Bach). It’s about a
connection between music and people. Music, in general, and piano
playing in particular, exist to enrich the lives of both players and
listeners. It is art. It’s supposed to be fun. As teachers, we must
get this point across to our students, especially those with
perfectionistic tendencies or we risk losing them to the frustration
of trying to reach the unattainable.

So how can we as teachers help our
students have a healthy view of their relationship with the piano?
After letting my student know how much I appreciate her desire to do
a great job, I try, as much as possible, to set her up for success.
If that means she only learns a small amount of music during those
first few weeks, that’s fine. I am trying to build a trust
relationship. I want my student to feel comfortable and confident. I
can pile on some more work later on after she has experienced a
measure of success.

As time goes by, and I have the
opportunity to get to know my student better, I start talking about
the fact that none of us are perfect all of the time. I tell them
even the great artists make mistakes from time to time. This is when
I start to challenge my student with more work and more difficult
music. I want her to feel confident, but I don’t want her to become
bored because the music is too easy. I have found that most
perfectionistic students are very bright and need to be challenged.

Recitals are particularly tricky for
the perfectionist piano student. In my studio, recital attendance is
a requirement, so everyone has to play. Some students are very
nervous about playing in front of others, so I music make sure that
the recital is a positive experience. I do this by making sure the
recital piece they will perform is well within reach, and leave
plenty of time for the student to learn the music. Many times I will
play a duet with my students at the first recital to take the
pressure off. I have the students play for each other and I tell
parents to have the kids play for everyone who comes into the house.
I do everything in my power to ensure that my students have a
successful first recital experience.

Success begets success; Especially for
the perfectionistic piano student!

I am so excited when I discover a piano
student who wants to strive for perfection. I know this student has
the potential to become a fine musician. With the right nurturing the
sky’s the limit.

If you like this content please share it

If you would like free music and resources for your studio

button